Lebanese Musician Samir Sfeir kidnapped by Saudi Authorities.

Reason behind kidnapping Samir Sfeir

  • Political

    Votes: 8 61.5%
  • Security

    Votes: 3 23.1%
  • Both

    Votes: 2 15.4%
  • Other

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    13

JB81

Legendary Member
No! Arrest is done by governments, kidnapping by assailants

Bachir was kidnapped once by the palestinians
Khashoogi was kidnapped by the saudis in turkey

Sfeir was arrested by the saudi authorities
Loujain al-Hathloul was arrested by the saudi authorities

Loujain al-Hathloul was also later kidnapped by the saudi authorities

I would stand with anyone arrested by the saudis!

What's the difference between Kashougi and Sfeir, when both are invited by the Saudis than disappear?

Would you stand with anyone arrested by the Syrians or the Iranians? So, is it ok to Syrian authorities to arrest Lebanese?
 

Rock

Legendary Member
What's the difference between Kashougi and Sfeir, when both are invited by the Saudis than disappear?

Would you stand with anyone arrested by the Syrians or the Iranians? So, is it ok to Syrian authorities to arrest Lebanese?
Was my post not clear enough with the comparison?

Syria, iran, saudi... not the best examples of fair trials and balanced justice

And now in lebanon too :p
 

JB81

Legendary Member
Was my post not clear enough with the comparison?

Syria, iran, saudi... not the best examples of fair trials and balanced justice

And now in lebanon too :p

No, you are not clear enough

When someone is dragged to a place, than disappears... does it sound like an arrest or a kidnap?
 

HalaMadrid

Well-Known Member
Orange Room Supporter
Words have meanings
If we use them to suit our political agenda, we are living in 1984's Orwell book
Kidnapped and Arrested are two different words
Fix the tittle, then we can have a proper discussion
If what's in the OP is right that the Saudi government has not officially confirmed his arrest and they have not allowed anyone to see him. Then he's not "arrested" (a legal action for a state to undertake) nor "kidnapped" he's actually forcibly disappeared.
 

Nonan

Legendary Member
Orange Room Supporter
What a surprise from the so-called "Defenders of the cause". If a civil war would break out today, they would kill more Christians than non-Christians.
As an Investment Management professional, I have to remind you that past performance is not an indicator of future performance...
 

Viral

Active Member
If what's in the OP is right that the Saudi government has not officially confirmed his arrest and they have not allowed anyone to see him. Then he's not "arrested" (a legal action for a state to undertake) nor "kidnapped" he's actually forcibly disappeared.
You might want to ask Sa3doon about those technicalities. Then again, he might be staying at the Ritz Carlton having an affair hiding away from his wife courtesy of MBS;)
 

TayyarBeino

Legendary Member
"ليبانون ديبايت" ينشر تفاصيل جديدة عن إعتقال سمير صفير
المصدر: ليبانون ديبايت | الثلاثاء 27 نيسان 2021

"ليبانون ديبايت"

عَلِم "ليبانون ديبايت" أن الملحّن سمير صفير موقوف منذ 7 أيام، بعد مداهمة منزله من قبل عناصر تابعة لأحد الأجهزة الأمنية السعودية.

وفي المعلومات، أن السفير اللبناني في السعودية طلب من عائلة صفير عدم تسريب الخبر إلى الإعلام ريثما تتم حلحلة الموضوع بالطرق الدبلوماسية، الأمر الذي أخّر معرفة اللبنانيين به، إلى أن سرّب "ليبانون ديبايت" الخبر.

وفي تفاصيل المداهمة، أن مجموعة أمنية تفوقُ الـ10 أشخاص دخلت منزل صفير من دون سلاح، وطلبت منه أن يزوّدها بجهازالـ"Laptop" الخاص به، ليردّ صفير على العناصر بأنه لا يملك أي جهاز، وعندما سألوه عن الأجهزة الأخرى التي يمتلكها، سلّمهم جهازين "Iphone"، الأول بخط لبناني، والثاني بخط سعودي، وبعدها فتّشوا المنزل تفتيشاً دقيقاً، ولم يعثروا على أي ممنوعات، وعلى الأثر، اصطحبوا صفير والجهازين الذي كانا بحوزته إلى سجن "دلهون".

ومنذ ذلك الحين انقطعت أخبار صفير الذي تواصل مع عائلته مرة واحدة فقط، لإعلامهم عن مكان تواجده.

والجدير ذكره، أن صفير الذي له العديد من الأعمال الفنية مع مغنيين لبنانيين وخليجيين لم يلقَ أي تعاطف، باستثناء قلّة قليلة منهم، التي غرّدت مُطالبة بمعرفة مصيره والإفراج عنه.

 

Manifesto

Legendary Member
Orange Room Supporter
Words have meanings
If we use them to suit our political agenda, we are living in 1984's Orwell book
Kidnapped and Arrested are two different words
Fix the tittle, then we can have a proper discussion
I just love how Kataebis and LFers go to great lengths to defend their Saudi masters.
 

TayyarBeino

Legendary Member


كشف السفير اللبناني في السعودية فوزي كبارة في اتصال مع
tayyar. org
أن الملحن والفنان " سمير صفير موقوف لدى الاجهزة الامنية السعودية قيد التحقيق وليس مخطوفا والتحقيق سري وكل ما تسمعونه بالإعلام هو تكهنات، قد تصيب وقد تخطئ."

 
If we have two liquids not exactly the same but not very different either. Would they have the same boiling point temperature ?

The two liquids are jamal khashoggi and samir sfeir, which one will evaporate faster in thin air ?
 

TayyarBeino

Legendary Member


عقد تكتل لبنان القوي إجتماعه الدوري إلكترونياً برئاسة النائب جبران باسيل وأصدر البيان الآتي:

4 - يدعو التكتل الحكومة اللبنانية الى متابعة قضيّة الفنان سمير صفير الموقوف في المملكة العربية السعودية من منطلق حماية حقه بالدفاع عن نفسه وعودته الى اهله، ويؤكّد التكتل متابعته هذه القضية من منطلق حرصه على حسن العلاقات بين لبنان والمملكة العربية السعودية.

 
When Khashoggi was dismembered in the Saudi Embassy in Turkey, MBS was enjoying the scene remotely. This is what they say at least.

Samir Sfeir tried to dismember several times the protest and he ignored that angry people is the voice of God. He was trying to dismember God's voice.

Let's see whether MBS will passively enjoy Samir Sfeir's scene, or on the contrary will pick the chainsaw like our lovely Doomguy and finish off the job himself
 
Last edited:
The Lebanese foreign ministry need to find the kidnapped Lebanese in the Syrian dungeons. As for Samir Sfeir he is not kidnapped he was arrested for Saudi national security issue. He made his bed he can sleep in it. He shoould have gone to Iran for his Covid Vaccine.
God bless KSA

God curse Syria forever.
 

TayyarBeino

Legendary Member
Chou ra7 ya3mol hal mastool bil KSA ?
The guy made a stupid decision to go to KSA and fell for the trap but that does not absolve the Saudis from whatever this is.


Additionally, the Saudi Health Ministry responded to some comments questioning Sfeir’s eligibility to take the vaccine in Saudi Arabia.

The Ministry clarified in a statement, without naming Sfeir, that he is “a resident of Saudi Arabia with a valid residence permit under the sponsorship of a private company and falls within the age groups covered by the vaccine for this stage.”

January 8, 2021
 
Additionally, the Saudi Health Ministry responded to some comments questioning Sfeir’s eligibility to take the vaccine in Saudi Arabia.

The Ministry clarified in a statement, without naming Sfeir, that he is “a resident of Saudi Arabia with a valid residence permit under the sponsorship of a private company and falls within the age groups covered by the vaccine for this stage.”

January 8, 2021
I hope he will stay for a very long time in Saudi's prisons.

He made so much harm to the 17 October revolt and that has consequences.

That will teach him not to shut the voice of God, that is, the anger of a distressed people.
 
b sharafak!!
there is a difference between political differences between two people and kidnapping of a lebanese citizen by a foreign country, especially that they don't reveal the reasons.
Even if Bassil was "arrested" without apparent reasons, YOU MUST TAKE HIS SIDE.
Mich 3am bi khallouneh ekhod his side
 
Top